City Hall Artwork Missing from Lightfoot Aide's Office

A 3-foot-by-5-foot abstract painting by artist Bill Cass, estimated to be worth up to $1,000, has vanished from the City Hall office formerly occupied by ex-Mayor Lori Lightfoot's chief operating offi

CJ
Chloe Jenkins

June 21, 2026 · 2 min read

An empty space on a wall in a city hall hallway, where a valuable painting has been reported missing.

A 3-foot-by-5-foot abstract painting by artist Bill Cass, estimated to be worth up to $1,000, has vanished from the City Hall office formerly occupied by ex-Mayor Lori Lightfoot's chief operating officer, Paul Goodrich. The publicly owned artwork disappeared between the end of 2021 and May 2023, prompting questions about the oversight of city assets, according to Wbez.

City Hall is entrusted with public assets, but its inventory systems are so deficient that a painting can disappear from a top official's office without a trace. This is a significant lapse in accountability for taxpayer-owned property.

The Inventory Failure and Its Implications

The missing artwork, a city property since the 1980s (Chicago Sun-Times), is not listed among the roughly 700 items in an inventory of city-owned art objects, according to Wirepoints. This omission reveals a fundamental systemic flaw in how City Hall tracks its valuable assets.

Its decades-long presence exposes a systemic disregard for even minor public assets. If a relatively low-value, historically significant piece can disappear without a trace and not be in the official inventory, it raises serious questions about the fate of higher-value or less visible public assets. The disappearance of a taxpayer-owned painting, despite its long history within the city's collection, yet absent from the official inventory, reveals Chicago City Hall's asset management system is fundamentally broken, leaving public property vulnerable to unchecked loss.

Last Known Whereabouts and Broader Oversight Concerns

The painting had been hanging in the City Hall office of Paul Goodrich, former Chief Operating Officer for Mayor Lightfoot, from around the end of 2021 until May 2023, according to Wbez. This specific timeframe and location are crucial for understanding its disappearance.

If a 3-foot-by-5-foot abstract painting can vanish from a chief operating officer's office without a trace, it suggests a broader culture of lax oversight where public assets, regardless of value, are treated as disposable rather than protected. This incident demands enhanced asset management protocols within City Hall.

Without immediate and comprehensive reforms to asset tracking and accountability, more taxpayer-owned property is likely to go missing from City Hall.